Best Quality, Best Priced Roofers in Columbus
We're experienced, fast, friendly, and we clean up after ourselves when the job is done.
Our roofing services are unparalleled in our quality and affordability.
Your Roof. Our Reputation.
Amish Roofers was founded by Eli Hershberger in 2018. We have completed roofing installations all across South Central Indiana. Whether your job is residential or commercial, metal or shingle, our system, and our processes allow us to guarantee the quality roofing we are known and respected for, giving you lasting protection and peace of mind.
Our highly skilled crews and staff members are Amish, Mennonite, and non-Amish alike.
Committed to quality—rain or shine.
Serving Columbus & Bartholomew County Indiana
Amish Roofers are proud to protect the homes and Businesses in the City of Columbus and Bartholomew County. As a roofing company based in Central Indiana, we understand your needs, our Indiana weather, and your expectations—and we deliver roofing you can count on. Our quality and customer service centers around you. Amish Roofer's extensive roofing knowledge, quality service and top-notch experience gives you peace of mind and a finished product to love.
We deliver experience you can see and integrity you can trust.
Designed for Your Home. Built for Central Indiana Weather
Indiana storms can be unpredictable, but your roof shouldn’t be. From high winds and heavy rain to hail and sudden temperature swings, storm damage can quietly compromise your roof’s integrity. Our experienced roofing team specializes in identifying storm-related damage early and can install a metal or asphalt roof to battle the elements for years to come.
Our roofing is built for Indiana Weather — From Heat Waves to Hailstorms.
Protect Your Investment with Expert Commercial Roofing
Your roof isn’t just a structure—it’s a critical asset protecting your building, your operations, and your bottom line. Our commercial roofing installations are designed for long-term performance, energy efficiency, and minimal maintenance. With metal roofs or asphalt shingle projects for small businesses, schools or churches to large-scale facilities, we install roofing systems engineered to withstand weather, foot traffic, and time—without disrupting your daily operations. If you’re looking for a roofing partner who understands commercial buildings, respects your timelines, and stands behind their work—we’re ready to get started.
Let’s schedule a site evaluation and build a roofing solution that works as hard as your business does.
Roofing Colors & Materials
Choosing the right roof color is about more than just looks—it affects your home’s curb appeal, energy efficiency, and even resale value.
Where to Begin with Selecting your Roofing Color
🧱 1. Match Your Home’s Exterior Style & Color
Brick Homes: Go with warm tones like brown, black, or dark grey.
Stone Exteriors: Choose subtle tones like dark grey or slate.
Siding (vinyl/wood): Coordinate with siding color—contrast for visual interest, match for cohesion.
Bold Exteriors: Stick with neutral roof colors to avoid clashing.
Metal Roofing Color Options
Metal roofing offers exceptional durability, energy efficiency, and modern style—making it a smart choice for Indiana’s unpredictable weather. Available in a variety of panel profiles, finishes, and color options, metal roofs can suit everything from classic farmhouses to contemporary homes. Choose from timeless neutrals, rich earth tones, or bold modern colors designed to resist fading, rust, and corrosion. With long lifespans and low maintenance needs, metal roofing provides lasting protection while enhancing curb appeal. Our team helps you select the right metal style and color to match your home’s design and performance needs.
Amish Roofers offers over 20 metal roof colors.
Please Note: Colors displayed on electronic monitors are for approximation of actual colors.
Asphalt Shingle Color Options
Asphalt shingles offer the perfect balance of durability, affordability, and style—making them one of the most popular roofing choices for Indiana homes. Available in a wide range of profiles and color options, today’s asphalt shingles can complement everything from traditional to modern designs. Whether you prefer classic earth tones, bold architectural shades, or lighter colors that reflect heat, there’s an option to match your home’s look while standing up to wind, rain, hail, and seasonal temperature swings. Amish Roofers helps you choose the right shingle and color combination to enhance curb appeal and provide long-lasting protection.
For Roofing Replacement 100% Guaranteed
We are experienced, fast, friendly, and yep, we clean up after ourselves when the job is done. We take special care when it comes to the crown of your home or business, which you will be able to see in the results. Our roofing services are unparalleled in their quality and affordable pricing; our contractors are the most professional and very detail-oriented. No matter what kind of project you need done, our experienced roofing contractors can take care of it. We always give our finest effort, and we always perform reliable work using the safest methods.
Financing Options Available
Service Finance Company, LLC offers financing solutions for products such as: HVAC, Windows, Doors, Siding, Sunrooms, Flooring, Water Treatment, Plumbing, Solar, Roofing, Insulation and more. Get a great rate through Service Finance Company, The Process is fast, easy and paperless - and we can get you taken care of when we stop by to look at your roof. Funds are available quickly, so your project can begin right away!
Schedule a Free Roof Inspection Today
Don’t wait for small roofing issues to turn into costly repairs. Whether you’re concerned about storm damage or simply want peace of mind, a professional roof inspection can catch problems early and protect your home. Our experienced team provides honest evaluations and clear recommendations you can trust. Schedule your roof inspection today and take the first step toward long-lasting protection.